The Pope's Exorcist

I have a soft spot for supernatural themes, so I'm giving this one an extra star. Without Russell Crowe, it might feel like a B-movie, but he elevates it. Julius Avery did a fantastic job technically, and I'm glad someone other than James Wan tackled an exorcism horror. It shows that this genre can be approached differently. While James Wan's exorcism films have become a bit stale and recycled, this one worked pretty well for me. It's not the scariest, but with Russell in the lead and based on a true story, it adds a solid legend to the mix. Overall, I'm satisfied. (10/23/2023)

A classic exorcism story cut from Dan Brown and a Lambretta scooter advertisement. The added layer might have been the thesis about a Vatican conspiracy (oops, not us, it's him!), but in the end, everything fizzled out in a generic conclusion, after which Father Amorth need not worry about nightmares (those will come only in 1998 after the World Cup). Holding it together over the holy water is Maximus Scooterus, whose quirky priest I could easily imagine in a pair with James Woods from Scary Movie. If Hopkins and Pryce can be Two Popes, then Two Exorcists should get a chance too. (05/26/2023)

Congratulations to the filmmakers for finding a meaningful reason to make the thousandth exorcism horror film with the potential for epic expansion into sequels. However, I won’t congratulate them for not being scared of their own idea, and without flinching, follow a template we’ve seen a thousand times before. A template entertaining and well executed enough to be worth watching, but a template nonetheless. Russell Crowe is very good, some of the visual effects and the generic demonic voice not so. (05/02/2023)

It's an interesting effort. The cast is quite enticing - I don't think Russell would play in any BS movie. The story is good, and the execution is also solid, although there are a few weaker moments. Overall, I consider it well-done. I never expect a cultural masterpiece from a horror movie, but rather a fun and relaxing experience, which is exactly what this provided. The fact that it is based on a real character and a "real" story of an exorcist adds to its appeal. I'm curious to know how many people ordered books by Amorth after watching the movie :) I would give it three stars, which is an above-average rating for this genre. (05/05/2023)

Just another exorcism movie. Or another generic genre addition that unfortunately spits out all its plot and reveals all the demon scenes in the trailer and has nothing to dazzle with. Russell Crowe is a nice change from the jaded Mr. and Mrs. Warren, and his role as a satirical rebel priest is solid, but otherwise it's just a classic template that doesn't stand out in any aspect. Visually fine, atmospherically average and kind of middle of the road in terms of craftsmanship. I expected more. (04/23/2023)