The Illusionist

Surprisingly more entertaining than The Prestige for me. Edward Norton steals the whole film for himself, he is intelligent, charismatic, insightful and a very talented illusionist. The period in which the film takes place suited me very well, the romance is apt and not annoying and the overall flow of the plot is very brisk and not boring, so for me I'm satisfied, I don't even know why I put the film off for so long. Very good. 80%. (12/10/2014)

I wouldn't have expected such a bland performance from Norton (another Italian Job?), and maybe he didn't even know what ear-splitting lines the script would force him to let out of his mouth. The only thing that keeps this below-average fable afloat, with the look of a slightly more expensive TV production, is the great (and better from film to film) Giammatti, while the final Shyamalan-like twist stands on very shaky legs. And I might rename the whole film to "Hologram Man" – Eisenheim's stunts in the second half were closer to science fiction than to illusory shenanigans (nasty nitwit Lima). (01/09/2007)

The Illusionist is very unlucky, since it directly clashed in time with another film about magic, Christopher Nolan's The Prestige, against which it doesn't stand a chance, even without closer examination. While the second film is characterized by its darkness and nerve-wracking complex twists, Neil Burger makes do with only a slightly mysterious atmosphere and simply drawn characters – good-evil-righteous-beautiful. Nevertheless, I liked this straightforward fairytale, even though it has serious flaws of logic in its explanations, but thanks to the suitable magical mood and clearly defined genre rules, it is more than pleasant in its simplicity. (02/03/2007)

Quite an interesting subject. I've always liked wizards, and setting it in the era of Franz Joseph is quite fitting. There are interesting actors involved, and the magic is connected to a death case. It's not bad at first glance, but it's all done inconsistently. It's neither a proper thriller nor a proper romance, and even the magic feels overly reliant on special effects. Edward Norton is excellent, as always, and Giamatti, he's consistently great. Overall, though, I have mixed feelings rather than enthusiasm. (04/01/2014)

A well executed mystery film that is one big illusion with a meticulously crafted plot and a surprising ending. There is nice music, beautiful costumes and period atmosphere. And most of all, perfect illusions whose explanation is just another illusion. In short, a film to get swept away with a lovely cast and a great story. (09/25/2010)