The Illusionist

As a historical blockbuster for the consumerist audience, The Illusionist features oversimplified characters and emotions created by tacky lighting that blurs the image beyond their faces, like in the worst soap operas. On the other hand, the story is nicely fast-paced and Bratislava and Prague on the background of Philip Glass’s music seem irresistible, almost fairytale-like. It’s a bit surprising that the most remarkable character (and performance) is not delivered by Edward Norton, but by Paul Giamatti. Had it not been for the lame attempt to impress us with the point, which any thinking viewer can guess at least ten minutes beforehand, and especially all the plot holes and half-baked execution, I might have given it a “guilty” four stars. (02/14/2009)

A very interesting topic overall. I have always liked magicians, and setting it in the era of Franz Josef is quite appropriate. There are interesting actors involved, and on top of that, magic is connected to a death case. At first glance, it's not bad, but the whole thing is done somewhat inconsistently. It's neither a proper thriller nor a proper romance, and the magic itself is a bit too trick-oriented. Edward Norton is excellent, as well as Giamatti, as always. However, overall, it gives more conflicting feelings than enthusiasm. (04/01/2014)

Surprisingly more entertaining than The Prestige for me. Edward Norton steals the whole film for himself, he is intelligent, charismatic, insightful and a very talented illusionist. The period in which the film takes place suited me very well, the romance is apt and not annoying and the overall flow of the plot is very brisk and not boring, so for me I'm satisfied, I don't even know why I put the film off for so long. Very good. 80%. (12/10/2014)

A well executed mystery film that is one big illusion with a meticulously crafted plot and a surprising ending. There is nice music, beautiful costumes and period atmosphere. And most of all, perfect illusions whose explanation is just another illusion. In short, a film to get swept away with a lovely cast and a great story. (09/25/2010)

If it weren't for (and this is my eternal problem) the unsympathetic Norton, it would have been better. This magical thing boasts a nice period atmosphere, music and ubiquitous illusions that make it almost a fairy-tale spectacle. But the film is slow, rather long and often boring. The filmmakers must have realized this, so in the last third they got things going again. Due to this the end is... Better. But it won't save The Illusionist. (07/10/2010)