Stranger Than Fiction

Just as the current trend in comedies is to showcase the enlightening transformation of an cold office fish into a human being and throw in some chick as a bonus, so Stranger Than Fiction reeks of a spasmodic attempt to define itself against that type of comedy, even though the basic synopsis is the same. Indeed – a bored guy with a face, Will Ferrell, working in the IRS and having no contact with anyone picks up a tattooed, impulsive, left-wing baker, Maggie Gyllenhaal. How many times have we seen this – Fight Club, Yes Man, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Wanted,... Which sucks, because the main idea of blending a literary with a real character is actually a promising one, and the film is even funny and endearing at a few moments. Unfortunately, though, it somehow doesn't bring anything new to the table. (08/25/2010)

Creator-chameleon Marc Foster has again chosen a subject that we wouldn’t expect from him - a variation on The Truman Show. And, as usual, he filmed an outstanding picture that is like all of his previous ones, although it trips up a little with the not completely kosher ending. However, this time this comes after such a gush of originality, playful narrative techniques, disarming ideas and visual tricks that it doesn’t really matter. Everything here is like clockwork - the actors is outstanding, the screenplay too and if you add to this the sure-handed and ingenious directing, it’s hard not to fall in love with this story about this boring guy, Harold Crick. Despite the ending which I would have preferred if it had come a few minutes sooner. (07/25/2007)

I'm pretty amazed at how overrated this film is. I was expecting much more fun, but the result is just an ordinary dramatic love story, cut with a quite original, but drastically underused, idea about a man who is both real and a character in the novel of an author who is about to kill him in the final book. Unfortunately, the central element is not used at all, and jokes are spared as much as possible – not only did I not laugh out loud once, but I literally didn't laugh once during the entire film. And that's quite a problem for a comedy. What I liked is the quality acting duo of Will Ferrell and Maggie Gyllenhaal. Ferrel has a very serious role, very unexpected for him compared to his current black humor troll work. All in all, it's a mere drama without a hint of humour or a more substantial use of the main idea, which, although going very much against the grain, bored me madly... (12/28/2022)

I enjoy stories where the stories themselves take center stage. Here, reality seamlessly blends with novelistic reality. Will Ferrell is absolutely incredible, and I still regret that he doesn't make more films like this and instead focuses so much on over-the-top comedies. But the cast is generally awesome in this film. It’s touching and romantic, but not overly so, and there is just the right amount of drama. Perhaps the ending could have been different. Mostly, though, the film gives you a sense of harmony. (03/23/2014)

The story of the life of Harold Crick, a man of extraordinary ordinary qualities who was the main character of a novel with a tragic ending, won me over mainly because of the performances Emma Thompson, Dustin Hoffman, Will Ferrell and Jake Gyllenhaal, the well thought out plot and the elaborate script. In short, an extraordinary film with an elite cast, which perfectly combines elements of comedy and tragedy. (02/05/2011)